June 20, 2018: “Read & Tell”

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

Marla read Lawn Boy Jonathan Enison he creates excellent characters Rating 5
Tim1. Chemistry by Weike Wang 4.5/5
Wry, unique, touching tale of the limits of parental and partnership pressure as Student tries to deal with her life before, during and after her quest for a PhD in Chemistry.

2. The Foundation Trilogy by Isaac Asimov 5/5
A landmark of science fiction’s “Golden Age,” Isaac Asimov’s Foundation Trilogy is composed of the novels Foundation, Foundation and Empire, and Second Foundation, It is set in the far future, Foundation envisions a Galactic Empire that has thrived for 12,000 years, but whose decline into an age of barbarism lasting some thirty millennia is imminent–if the predictions of renegade psycho-historian Hari Seldon are accurate. Hoping to shorten the interval of this impending new Dark Age, Seldon convinces the Empire’s Commission of Public Safety to allow him to create a Foundation on which the future Empire will be erected.

Pam read The Overstory by Richard Powers.  About 9 characters that are woven together.  He has done a tremendous amount of research on trees.  History of eco activist of 1970 & 80’s.   Cerebral book, give it a 5.
Kjersti is still reading The Woman Who Would be King by Kara Cooney.  Great informatio about Egypt but difficult writing style so gives it a 2.75
Lilly read Barbarian Days.
Mimi, The Arcanum: The Extraordinary True Story by Janet Gleeson.  Book about porcelain, the technique was perfected by Chinese. Rated 4.5
Billie read Nothing to Envy by Barbara Demick, a L.A. times journalist.  She covered North Korea and she wrote about their journey into the famine.  Not a long read but informative. 5 rating
Jon is reading Ron Chernow’s Hamilton, he has a gift for making the time come alive.  4.5
Paul read, Fascism A Warning by Madeleine Albright.  She defines fascism and follows through with classic fascist leaders.  She points out that fascism was successful for a few years and solved problems.  Includes modern fascists along with Trump.  5
Kathleen read Circe by  Madeleine Miller  The daughter of Helios, the sun god.  She was banned.   She is a wise woman who knows a lot about herbs and magic and is a monster. She gave it a 5.
Shelagh also read Circe.  She likes books that tell the story of a woman who was overlooked in history.  Great read, fleshing out of Circe. 5 rating as well
Jennifer read Wolf Hollow by Lauren Wolk set in 1942 small farming town.   Coming of age story involving prejudice and sociopath.  Many functional strong family relationships within the story dealing with characters who inject the dysfunction.  5
Catherine, her first ridge readers, is reading Orange World by Karen Russell in the New Yorker, where a woman makes a deal with the devil while she is pregnant.   Vampires in the Lemon Grove, reminds her of this article. gets 5 out of 5
Maribeth read All the Light We cannot See, set in Nazi occupied France during WW2.
Karen read the novel Pachinko by Min Jin Lee.  She follows 4 generations of Koreans starting in Korea in the 20th century to Japan.  Loved reading it because the characters are so flushed out.    Suffer immense cruelty and prejudice but are a loyal family who stay true to each other.  History has failed us but no matter.



May 16, 2018: “Read & Tell”

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

SonyaThe Arcanum: The Extraordinary True Story by Janet Gleeson, 5.0:  Read the description from Karen who read it last month.  Totally agree with her – who would ever have thought that the history of porcelain could be so fascinating?!

Marla, The Fire This Time:  A New Generation Speaks About Race by Jessmyn Ward, 3.5: collection of short essays, memoir, and a few poems – some are fabulous, some are mediocre.

Tim, The Death of Chaos by L.E. Modesitt Jr, 4.5:  This is the sequel to the Magic of Recluse in which Lerris continues his growth as a master of order magic and his life fighting the chaos that threatens his friends and Recluse.

A Higher Loyalty (Truth, Lies and Leadership) by James Comey 4.8:  A fascinating book about recent events and insights into the life of this former US Attorney, assistant Attorney General and FBI director.

The Word for World is Forest by Ursula K Le Guin 4.0:  In this novella terran colonists have taken over the planet locals call Athshe, meaning “forest,” rather than “dirt,” like their home planet Terra. They follow the 19th century model of colonization: felling trees, planting farms, digging mines & enslaving indigenous peoples. The natives are unequipped to comprehend this. They’re a subsistence race who rely on the forests & have no cultural precedent for tyranny, slavery or war. The invaders take their land without resistance until one fatal act sets rebellion in motion & changes the people of both worlds forever.

Pam, A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies and Leadership by Jim Comey, 5.0:  Surprised at how good it was – not ghostwritten, ethics in general and ethics in government – a bit about his young life, and then with Bush, and then of course with Trump – fabulous book, thoughtful, beautifully written, it gave her hope.

Kris, The Leopard, by Giuseppe di Lampedusa, 5.0:   Italian classic set in Sicily during Italian unification.  The main character is a Sicilian nobleman trying to navigate the changes. Gives an idea of daily life, of both rich and poor, during the period and the history of Sicily with its numerous conquerors and occupiers. Haven’t quite finished the book, but so far she gives it a 5.0  (And, it’s a classic. . . .)

Paul, Republican Like Me: How I Left the Liberal Bubble and Learned to Love the Right by Ken Stern, 4.0:  He lives in the right-wing and tries to learn what they stand for – for example, gun control, evangelicals.  He does need a better editor, but it is a good uncomfortable book to read.  Even though it is not really well-written, because it pushes him out of his comfort zone, he gave it the rating of 4.0.

Kjerste, The Turtles of Oman by Naomi Shihab Nye, 5.0:  A young adult book, story of a 3rd grade kid with parents who are professors – moving to Michigan from Oman, spends time with his grandpa, moving adventure, got to know a little about the country, teaching some language of Oman.

Dave – Read mostly about prison reform and recidivism

Shelagh, What You are Getting Wrong about Appalachia by Elizabeth Catte, 5.0:  Much welcome correction to Hillbilly Elegy.  She is a historian and community activist.  J.D. Vance has many ties with right-wing communities.  About rich people buying resources and turning it into a company town.  Different areas in Appalachia are very different from each other.

Kathleen, Mister Monkey: A Novel by Francine Prose, 4.5:  She was in Sicily and didn’t get lots of reading done, but she did read this book.  It is a children’s book which turns into a musical  – off-off-off-off-Broadway children’s musical, moves between characters.

Karen, The House of Broken Angels by Luis Alberto Urrea, 4.5:  She listened to his interview on NPR – frustrated a bit by the very complicated family tree – yes, there is drug, murder, cancer, but it is very funny – it is fun to spend time with these people – 4.5 for now and maybe 5.0 when she reads it again.

Lilly, What Happened by Hilary Clinton, 4.0: It was good, a brilliant thoughtful woman – no real surprises – how can they be honest with themselves with such a complex situation and such a short time.  For example, when she says “I take responsibility for such and such” – how can she be so sure of what she did and didn’t have responsibility for.

Mimi, You Think It, I’ll Say It by Curtis Sittenfield, 4.25: A collection of short stories.

Hawley, The Punch, 4.0: Novel about 2 brothers, their addled, aging mother, and a plot involving bigamy, among other things. 

Perotta, Joe College, 3.5:  got it out of a little library.  I think it’s one of his earlier ones.  Eh. 
Benjamin, The Swans of 5th Avenue, sort of fiction, sort of NF, 2.75: another pick from a little library.  A lightly fictionalized account of Truman Capote’s falling out with the society divas of NYC.  A little goes a long way.  2.75
Wolitzer, The Female Persuasion, 4.5: Meg Wolitzer’s latest, about young feminists vs. old- guard feminism.  I really liked it.  
Robertson, Testimony, MEMOIR, 4.0: I’ve always been a big fan of The Band, so I enjoyed Robbie Robertson’s memoir, which differs considerably from Levon Helm’s account! 
Abrams, All the Pieces Matter: the Inside Story of the Wire, 5.0:  The Wire was my all-time favorite TV show (I’ve only watched it 3 times, straight through).  Loved it. 

April 18, 2018: “Read & Tell”

The book discussion this evening was on Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward – lead by Pam.

Next book club meeting on 5/16:  Book Picks Night

Bring a book to recommend, each person gets to talk about their recommended book for a couple minutes, and after all have talked about their book, we each get to vote for 6 books. We then negotiate dates for leading the book discussions for the top 6 books.  All selected book club books are available at Phinney Books in paperback and, you get 15% off of the book.  There are only a few guidelines for selected books:

  • Must be in paperback
  • Must be available for purchase from Phinney Books


Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

Sonya, The Humans: A Novel, by Matt Haig, 4.75:  Based on part of the description, you could possibly describe this book as sci-fi but really it is just what the title says – being human. An alien takes over a human body and is repulsed but eventually becomes aware of how amazingly wonderful it is to be human. He is a thoughtful writer, made me laugh and shed a few tears.  I recommended another of his books to a friend who is suffering from depression – Reasons to Stay Alive.

Dave:  Other than the book club book, he read bits and pieces about a lot of things, including neuroscience.

Karen, The Arcanum: The Extraordinary True Story by Janet Gleeson, 5.0: It is about pasionn, greed, enslavement, theft – in essence, about porcelain. In the 18th century, the  royalty coveted porcelain – came only from China – and was very very very expensive – they would do anything for it.  One rich person traded 600 soldiers for 60 porcelain vases – it is a really thrilling read.

Tom, Country Dark by Chris Offutt, 4.8:  Read his review in the Phinney Book Newsletter #182.  He compares the author to Raymond Carver – he comes from rural Kentucky, and hasn’t published fiction for 20 years.  It is set in the 50’s through 70’s – comes back from Korea – country noir – well told and observed, page turner, phenomenal – 4.8.

Happiness by Aminta Forna, 4.7

Paul, Ideas of Heaven by Joan Silber, 4.74:  It is 5 or 6 stories that are linked together by a minor character who will be the major character in another story.  The general themes are “people becoming who they really are” and “people who have an idea of what will satisfy them or make them happy and what happens when they don’t get that.”

Deanna, Pachinko by Min Jin Lee, 4.5:  Loved reading it – a story over many generations and how the government and political decisions carried down to a personal level – the writing was beautiful – felt timeless.

Kris, House of Broken Angels by Luis Alberto Urrea, 5.0:  A family saga – mexican-american family – revolves around 2 events – funeral of matriarch and the 70th b-day of one of her sons – reaches back in time to tell the story – different mothers – really rich!

Pam, Brother I am Dying  by Edwidge Danticat, 4.0:  A memoir of growing up in Haiti – takes you right into the nasty gangs, she and her brother stayed behind in Haiti while parents went on to the U.S. – aunt and uncle raised them for awhile, but the dad and uncle were quite close – back and forth between the U.S. and Haiti – gave a good feeling for the life and the extreme poverty there.

Marla, Ill Will by Dan Shaon, 4.0:  This is a dark tale – really well written – about damaged people who go around damaging other people – not a favorite read.

Mimi, The Immortalitsts by Chloe Benjamin, 4.0:  About 4 siblings who live on the lower Eastside during a hot summer – they see a gypsy woman who predicts their lives – it is about how each of them deal with the information they were given – everything from short to long lives – how do you choose to live your life?

Jennifer, The War I Finally Won by Kimberly Brubaker Bradley, 4.75:  It is a young adult’s book which handles complex themes – two children who sneak away from their abusive mother by evacuating themselves from London – follows these children from 41 to 43 during WW2 – presents the time period really well.

Jon:  Went rafting down the green river in Utah which has an amazing landscape – found it a shame that Humboldt didn’t make it to that area – rivers cutting through rock and seeing the layers – he would have been quite fascinated!

Tim, The Immortal Irishman by Timothy Egan 4.8/:  (the Irish revolutionary who became an American hero).  This is the epic story of one of the most fascinating and colorful Irishman in nineteenth-century America. Meagher’s live sweeps through some of the key events in Irish and American history. After first showing his resistance to English rule and his violent opposition to it, we see him in the United States, where the almost equally vexing treatment of the Irish by American immigrants who had established themselves in the country a bit earlier than these Irish newcomers. Meagher stood out as one of the great public speakers of the age, and his heroism on the battlefields of the Civil War makes him a major, if peripheral figure in that conflict. But the genius of this books is how much it makes us understand so many things. The Irish Question, Resistance to English rule, Migration to America, The abuse of the Irish in the United States, The reasons why many went to war against the South, The Question of Slavery, The Civil War itself, along with many of its greatest battles, The end of the War, Western expansion, and we finally learn just how wild the wild west could be. All these aspects of Irish and American life are masterfully told..

The Magic of Recluce by L.E. Modesitt Jr 4.5:  Lerris, a bored magician’s apprentice, embarks on a quest for knowledge–called the dangergeld–during which he encounters the magic of the Chaos wizards and battles the Archenemy of Order.

Einstein’s Unfinished Symphony by Marcia Bartusiak 4.0:  (THE STORY OF A GAMBLE, TWO BLACK HOLES AND A NEW AGE OF ASTRONOMY).  Marcia Bartusiak reports on an aspect of Astronomy. She tells us about the new generation of observatories, showing the motivations of the detectors’ creators and the gamble they made to prove Einstein right when all other attempts had failed. She traces the quest of astronomers to build the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) detectors, the most accurate measuring devices humans have created, and the discovery of gravitational waves, revealing the brilliance, personalities, and luck required to start a new age of astronomy.

Sabbath as Resistance by Walter Brueggemann 4.0:  (Saying No to the CULTURE OF NOW)  Discussions about the Sabbath often center around moralistic laws and arguments over whether a person should be able to play cards or purchase liquor on Sundays. In this volume, the author writes that the Sabbath is not simply about keeping rules but rather about becoming a whole person and restoring a whole society. Importantly, Brueggemann speaks to a 24/7 society of consumption, a society in which we live to achieve, accomplish, perform, and possess. We want more, own more, use more, eat more, and drink more. Keeping the Sabbath allows us to break this restless cycle and focus on what is truly important.


March 21, 2018: “Read & Tell”

The book discussion this evening was on The Invention of Nature by Andrea Wulf – lead by Jon.

Next book club meeting on 4/18:  Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward lead by Pam.

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

Dave read School for Scandal by Richard Brinsley Sheridan and She Stoops to Conquer by Oliver Goldsmith. 5 star rating.
Jon read The Darling by Russell Banks.  3
Kjersti read Hamilton by Ron Chernow 3
Kathleen read the Monk of Mokha 5  Dave Eggers
Shelagh read 1947 When Now Begins Elisabeth Ashbrink 5
Leah read Eruption, Untold Story of Mount St. Helens by Steve Olson 4
Mimi read Bill Bryson’s One Summer 4
Tim read Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape our Decisions by
  Dan Ariely  5
Marla read Men Explain Things to Me Rebecca Solnit 4
Tom read All the Pieces Matter The Inside Story of the Wire Jonathan Abrams 5
Jennifer  read Just Mercy by Bryan Stephenson 4.5
Deanna read The Quartet by Joseph Ellis 3.5
Lilly read Sherman Alexie, You Don’t Have to Say You love me (unrated)

February 21, 2018: “Read & Tell”

The book discussion this evening was on When Women Were Birds by Terry Tempest Williams – lead by Sonya and Dave, and chosen by Cashew.  Everyone really enjoyed the book.  One woman admitted that she started it, decided she didn’t like it, put it down, picked it up again later, and after finishing it, bought several of the books for her friends!  Another person said that reading it felt like reading poetry!

Next book club meeting on 3/21:  The Invention of Nature by Andrea Wulf lead by Jon

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

Sonya, The Milk Lady of Bangalore: An Unexpected Adventure by Shoba Narayan, 3.5:  An Indian woman, her husband and children move back to India after some time in NYC. She writes of reintegrating with Indian life – in particular, there is a woman across the street from her apartment who has several cows from whom people buy their milk each morning – fresh from the cows’ teats.  She writes of her relationship with the milk lady, of the history of cows in India, and other aspects of her life.  I enjoyed it because it is giving me a flavor of life in Bangalore.

David, Musicophilia by Oliver Sacks, 5.0:  Almost anything by Oliver Sacks is fascinating.

Leah, An American Marriage by Tayari Jones, 3.5:  The husband is wrongfully convicted of rape and is put in jail, and eventually released. It is about how these events affect their marriage.  She found it more political than expected.  Each chapter has a different narrator.  Another woman in the group heard her interview on PBS – the author was amazing – very dynamic.

Kjerste, Lilian Boxfish Takes a Walk by Kathleen Rooney, 4.5: This woman tells you her life story as she walks – lives in NYC.  It is a fun story and based on true events.

Tom, Vengeance by Zachary Lazar, 4.5:  Not exactly sure why he picked it up.  It is called a novel but really seems to be autobiographical.  The protagonist shares his name and history with the author.  It is set in contemporary Louisiana, sees a passion play in the state prison, talks to one of the inmates who says he is innocent, it then shifts to inmates point of view.  At the end, Tom had forgotten that it was fiction, and was left floundering a bit – finally remembered it is fiction because the inmate was not in the acknowledgements at the end.  The author is very aware of his position as a white person, the writing is exquisite but not in a flashy way.

Shelagh, Dear Mr. You by Mary Louise Parker, 4.8:  It is a memoir written through letters – she writes to the various men in her life – cab driver, uncle of a somalian girl she adopted, former lover.  Very good writing.

Kathleen, The Silk Roads by Peter Frankopan, 5.0:  Sweeping history of last few thousand years showing that the world revolved and revolves around the countries of the Siulk Road from Chinga to Italy.  Showed how people were interconnected through interchange of culture, language, slaves, disease and trade. And, how governments and powerful people continue to make the same types of mistakes century after century.

Karen,  The Persian Boy by Mary Renault, 4.5:  A historical novel, the last 7 years of Alexander the Great’s life, campaigns up to India and back, learned about his campaigns and what kind of leader he was, why they followed him.  The device she uses is the persian boy who is the eunuch lover of King Darius, and then of Alexander.  He is a real boy, and it is very likely that Alexander did have those types of relationships.

Tim, The Grave’s a Fine and Private Place by Alan Bradley, 4.0:   Flavia de Luce novels – it starts with the father dying, then there is the aunt who is going to decide everything for them, the sisters go on a boat trip, get a better sense of who Dodger is.

A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles 5.0:  the 30-year saga of the Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, who is placed under house arrest inside the Metropol Hotel in Moscow in 1922.

The Book of Life by Deborah Harkness 4.0:  This is the third and final volume of the All Souls Trilogy that started with A Discovery of Witches. This is one of the few trilogies, that I have read, in which the final volume is the best of the three. As with the other volumes, the author packs this story with historical details in a wonderful magical setting.

Pam, We Were Eight Years in Power by Ta-Nehisi Coates, 5.0:  It is a collection of essays published in the Atlantic Magazine over the course of Obama’s presidency..  He takes a topic and drills down – very enlightening, challenging and intense – talks about the presidency and some of the positions which he disagrees with.  She found it fascinating – many things she didn’t know about before on how blacks were treated.

Paul, God: A Human History by Reza Aslan, 4.0:  He writes on the premise that how we organize our society is how we organize our spirituality.  The hunter-gatherer society had pantheism, societies with royalty have monotheism – it is an interesting idea and it appears to be generally true, though Hinduism is left out.

Kitty, Gilgamesh: A Novel by Joan London, 5.0:  Fabulous so far, small little book.

Mimi, Last Hope Island by Olson, 4.75:  Story of the contributions of the Poles Czechs, Norwegians to the Allied effort in WWII which the Britich & Americans never really acknowledge (arrogance was unbelievable).  Two people had it on their top 10 list for last year – it is worth it.

Best Mystery Stories of 2017, 3.5

A House Among the Trees by Glass, 3.75: Nice read, a little above average.






January 17, 2018: “Read & Tell”

The book discussion this evening was on American Romantic by Just Ward – lead by Marla.  It was a lively discussion with people who enjoyed the book and those who only finished it because it was for book club!  It always makes for interesting discussions when there are divided opinions.

Next book club meeting on 2/21:  When Women Were Birds by Terry Tempest Williams

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!”

Shawna, An Odyssey: A Father, A Son and an Epic by David Mendelsohn, 5.0:  It is non-fiction, a father attends the class his son is teaching bout The Odyssey.  They then go on a cruise to the places in The Odyssey.

Uncommon Text by Tom Hanks, 3.5:  Type writers are mentioned in every story – whether they are the subject or just mentioned.

Jon, A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini (Kite Runner author), 3.5:  Very good writer – does a good job with language and makes you care about the characters – but it is a relentlessly and terribly unhappy read – very difficult to read – portrait of young women in Afghanistan.

Paul, Notes From a Bottle Found on a Beach at Carmel by Evan S. Connell, 5.5!:   He rereads it every 4 or 5 years – it is a 200 page poem but doesn’t read as a poem.  There is mystery out there – writes about things that people believe are true – deals with some of the horrible things we do to each other – atomic bombs, inquisition, sailors – starts with inquisition and ends with a boat sinking.  He considers himself to be a sort of a groupie for this author.  There is a sense that there is so much more out there to know – mystery and exploring.

Sonya, Kristin Lavransdatter: The Wreath, The Wife, The Cross by Sigrid Undset, 5.0:  The best book read in a very long time.  It is 3 books spanning the life of a Norwegian woman in the 1300’s.  The author writes about the human condition so well you understand that we humans haven’t changed all that much since then.  And the characterization, and growth of the characters – well shoot, just can’t say enough about it.  This will definitely be reread and reread!

Dave, Kristin Lavransdatter, 5.0:  Also read it.  The author’s father was a medievalist.

Karen, A Gentleman in Moscow, by Amor Towles, 5.0: About a count who is captured by the Bolsheviks, escapes being executed, and is confined to a 5-star hotel for decades.  His small room in the attic faces the Kremlin.  He is a first class person – constantly cheerful, has genuine friendships – through the whole book you are spending time with him.  He was such an anecdote to the vulgarity and racism we are now experiencing.  It is the #1 book in Seattle for 2017.

Leah, Sense & Sensibility by Joanna Trollope, 3.0:  It is set in modern day England, followed the original story very closely – didn’t seem to fully translate to the modern times – it was fun, but would recommend the original.

Mimi, Prairie Fires: The American Dreams of Laura Ingalls Wilder by Caroline Fraser, 5.0:  A biography of Laura Ingalls Wilder, of her and her family – it is a history of the white settlement of the plains including how we destroyed the topsoil – it took a 1000 years to build an inch of topsoil.

Marla, Notwithstanding: Stories from an English Village by Louis deBernieres, 5.0:  Short stories which all take place in the same English village, old fashioned sense of humor, interconnected stories of life – sweet, bittersweet, old fashioned – if you want to read something which makes you feel good…




November 15, 2017: “Read & Tell”

Phinney Books, 7:30pm – Each person can talk about a book they have read during the past month and rate it from 0 to 5. Zero – “I really disliked it.” Five – “Best book I have recently read!” 
Next meeting, 1/17, will be American Romantic by Ward Just with the discussion lead by Marla.The discussion this evening was lead by Shelagh about The Death and Life of American Cities by Jane Jacobs.  I can’t begin to recount the discussion – other than it was very lively and interesting.  We stopped at 9:05 and could’ve kept going for at least another hour!

Kjerste, In the Midst of Winter by Isabel Allende, 3.0:  Good story about 3 people coming together – liked their backstories/adventures.

Tom, Queen of Spades by Michael Shou-Yung Shum, 4.75:  Picked it up on a whim, jumped in and had a ball.  The author has a couple of doctorates and has dealt poker in Lake Stevens.  It is set in Snoqualmie in a fictitious casino.  The writing is a bit clunky but the characters immediately come to life and the story zooms ahead.  A bit magical.  Thought it was a hoot and thoughtful at the same time.

Jon, The Sun Also Rises by Hemingway, 2.5:  Read it a long time ago, but don’t remember much of it from the first time.  Just didn’t get into it – didn’t do anything for me at all.  The story was interesting enough and flowed well, but the characters were putrid – the story even starts off with anti-Semitism.

Dave, Benjamin Franklin autobiography, 5.0:  Was pretty good.  Especially interested in the fact that he was living in Boston – which, at the time, was only about 10,000 in population.  Then went to London, a much bigger city, and enjoyed it very much – explains why he stayed there so long.  And did he really fly a kite?  Not really sure.  The writing is mostly a collection of letters to his son.

Sonya, The Choice, Embrace the Possible by Dr. Edith Eva Eger, 5.0:  It is a memoir in which she recounts surviving Auschwitz, but the main gist of the story is about how she chooses to live her life since then.  She is now in her 90’s, and is going strong as a psychologist.  The title not only refers to her choice on how she chooses to live her life, but also an incident in the book.  We can all learn from her!

Paul, The Long Haul by Finn Murphy, 2.5:  A bunch of bar stories – about him screwing up, about others screwing up – wouldn’t want to reread it.  It was a fast read, and interesting.

Karen, The Cloud Splitter by Russell Banks, 4.5:  It is about Tom Brown and is considered historical fiction.  A bit redundant – much repetition about what he felt about slavery and other issues.  Though the last part of the book really started moving – it was the part about going into Harper’s Ferry.

Kathleen, The Obelisk Gate (2nd book in the trilogy) by N.K. Jemisin, 4.5:  Talks about the cultures which have grown up around the changes in the earth.  There are characters who can control volcanic activity and earthquakes – both revered and feared.  Does a wonderful job.

Marla, Before the Wind by Jim Lynch, 4.0:  Like his stories and the way he writes – family saga built on the framework of sailing – great characters.

Shawna, A Piece of the World by Christina Baker Kline, 4.0:  It’s a fictional memoir of the woman depicted in Andrew Wyeth’s Christina’s World. It is engagingly written and provides food for thought. Note:  Even though Shawna was not able to attend, she did read the book and thought it was timely, given that she has recently moved to a city neighborhood. She thinks she moved to the right one.